This has been a most frustrating season for one of my favorite ongoing shows, Gilmore Girls. Coming off a terrific 5th season, the show's finest since it's freshman year, Gilmore Girls has fallen prey to some terrible choices in writing. The first half of the year revolved around the fractured relationship between Lorelai and Rory. While this was an interesting direction to go, it unfortunately deprived us of the show's most memorable quality; the brilliant chemistry between Lauren Graham and Alexis Bledel and the strong bond developed between their two characters over the first 5 years. Exploring a rift in that relationship is fine (which they had done before, and never better than in the 1st season Christmas two parter), but they spent way too much time with this.
It seems like part of the reasoning for this split was an excuse to delay Lorelai and Luke's wedding, and this theory gains more strength when the show introduces a long lost daughter for Luke that causes problems right after the Lorelai-Rory rift was repaired. You'd think that a storyline involving Luke's daughter would be a massive mistake and cause the show to slide quickly downhill. You'd be wrong. It's actually not even much of a problem and has been handled fairly well. In fact, in the most recent episode, young actress Vanessa Marano really seemed to fit in nicely with show's fast paced dialogue style.
The real problem is that Rory and her best friend Lane are stuck in terrible relationships that just do not make sense. Rory's current boyfriend is Logan, a character that has been dragging this show down for quite some time. He wasn't able to do much damage last year, but has now been added as a full time cast member. He's an annoying preppie jackass and the writers have given us very little reason to like him. It didn't help matters when we see Jess reappear twice this season, reminding us of a couple that actually had some chemistry.
Meanwhile, Lane has been stuck in a terrible romance for the past two seasons with bandmate Zack. Similar to the problem with Rory's romance, the writers don't give us much reason to like Zack. He was a jerk when they started dating, a jerk when they broke up, and still they have him acting like an ass after he's proposed marriage to her. Sadly, she accepted. The season seems to be winding down to a Lane-Zack wedding, instead of, I don't know, A LUKE-LORELAI WEDDING. It's sad because given the history of Lane's character throughout the show, her wedding should be a rich, fulfilling moment. Instead, it might very well ruin her character forever.
I don't have much hope for the future. Previews for the next few episodes don't lead me to believe the Zack-Lane wedding will be called off, and the actor playing Logan has been locked up for next season. The Luke-Lorelai wedding angst will probably be carried out as long as possible (although I hope I'm wrong). It's going to be a while before this show gets fixed, and at the moment I'm not very confident that it will ever happen.
P.S. Didn't there used to be a character on this show named Sookie? Just wondering.