It's finally time for me to share my thoughts on this year's fall TV premieres. After a weak fall season last year which saw only one decent show survive to a 2nd season (Everybody Hates Chris), the 2006 fall slate has several shows with the potential to be great and many more that are solid in their own right.
The best of the year is Ugly Betty, a risky adaptation of a popular telenovela. This original comedy turned into one of TV's most stylish and witty shows and doesn't look like it will slow down. Stepping into a very difficult lead role that could have easily been a dumb caricature, America Ferrara has been brilliant so far. Even better are the fantastic ratings in a competitive time slot. Good ratings for this show will hopefully lead to more original pilots next season, although that was unfortunately not the case following 2004's great fall season.
Heroes is the other great success of the fall season and has already been given a full 22 episode order. What makes Heroes great is the patience it displays in developing it's characters and storylines. Boasting a large cast of ordinary people with extraordinary powers, the show has kept the ensemble apart, slowly showing us how each of the individual heroes learn to deal with their powers. At times the show is slow moving, but you always get he feeling that it is buolding to something great, and there hasn't been something quite like that since the first season of Lost.
Other promising shows include Aaron Sorkin's dramedy Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip, easily the most hyped show of the fall. While it does not quite rise to the level of Sorkin's previous work, it is definitely a watchable show with witty dialogue and a terrific cast. Ratigns have been unimpressive, but it will likely finish out a full 1st season before a deciusion is made on it's fate. The Nine is ABC's drama following nine survivors of a hostage crisis. The stunning pilot episode was my favorite of the season, but week two's overreliance on flashy directing tricks shows a lack of confidence in the story and will get old very soon. Stick to the interesting characters and leave the Michael Bay directing handbook at home. Also problematic are the terrible ratings, which could spell an early exit for the show. Brothers & Sisters is a serious family drama with one of the best casts on TV. Calista Flockhart leads the ensemble and her instant likeability is one of this show's great charms. ABC expected better numbers for this show, but if it maintains it's current level I think a 2nd season will be in store.
There's also the Tina Fey's 30 Rock, a wild comedy about a late night TV show; The chessy, but fun sci-fi drama Jericho; and the charming romantic comedy Men in Trees. It says alot about this TV season that even the disappointing shows (Six Degrees, Friday Night Lights) have hteir own merits and aren't completely unwatchable. Having said that, I chose not to see Justice, Happy Hour, Til Death, The Class, 20 Good Years, or Shark; any of which could have easily fit that description.
Television is currently owned by lame procedurals and endless reality shows. Two years ago, we saw the premiere of three very original shows (Lost, Desperate Housewives, Veronica Mars) and at least two of them were extremely successful. Unfortunately, that did not lead to much creativity in 2005's fall slate. Ugly Betty and Heroes are victories for original, creative programming. Let's hope that the networks take notice and give us more. Sure, the procedurals are easy money but so is prostitution.